Showcase Weltblick f3,5/135mm vs. Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm vs. Summicron f2/90mm

Discussion in 'Adapted Lens Sample Image Showcase' started by fujidanny, Mar 28, 2013.

  1. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Hi,

    today i received two interesting 135mm lenses, that i wanted to compare with the wellknown Leica Summicron 90mm, despite of their different openings and focal lengths:

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm by Weltblick, M42 mount, adapted, 84mm long, incl. adapter 116mm, ca. 365g, Filter 49mm
    Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm bei Enna, München, M42 mount, adapted, 85mm long, incl. adapter 117mm, ca. 350g, Filter 49mm
    Summicron f2,0/90mm by Leica, Leica M mount, adapted, 79mm long, incl. adapter 88mm, ca. 540g, Filter E55

    The three lenses: Weltblick, Tele-Ennalyt, Summicron (from left to right)

    IMG_2199.
    M42-adapter, Leica-M-mount-adapter

    The scene is a handmade glass picture

    DSCF2016.
    Weltblick f3,5/135mm

    4,00m distance, the sun is about 3,5cm, the big letters about 3mm high ​

    I used Provia film modus at ISO800, clouded sky whitebalance, X-E1 on a tripod. All pictures are sooc jpeg's. I cropped them to the same size for better comparing. The photo of the Summicron is much more cropped than the other ones, because of 2/3 focal length. All lenses are adapted by an mount adapter.

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm full open / Summicron f2,0/90mm full open / Ennalyt f2,8/135mm full open
    Weltblick 135 f3,5.JPG Summicron 90 f2,0.JPG Ennalyt 135 f8.JPG

    You can see clearly the difference in between the 3 lenses.
    The Weltblick ist the sharpest, than the Summicron, after that the Tele-Ennalyt.

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  2. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Weltblick f3,5/135mm vs. Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm vs. Summicron f2/90mm at f5,6

    So, now we look at the lenses at f5,6:

    The scene is the same handmade glass picture, distance 4,00m, the sun is about 3,5cm, the big letters about 3mm high.

    I used Provia film modus at ISO800, clouded sky whitebalance, X-E1 on a tripod. All pictures are sooc jpeg's. I cropped them to the same size for better comparing. The photo of the Summicron is much more cropped than the other ones, because of 2/3 focal length. All lenses are adapted by an mount adapter.

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm at f5,6 / Summicron f2,0/90mm at f5,6 / Ennalyt f2,8/135mm at f5,6
    Weltblick 135 f5,6.JPG Summicron 90 f5,6.JPG Ennalyt 135 f5,6.JPG

    You can see clearly the difference in between the 3 lenses.
    Again the Weltblick ist the sharpest, than the Summicron, after that the Tele-Ennalyt. The Tele-Ennalyt appears to be pale. Furthermore the photo of the summicron is much more cropped.


    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  3. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Weltblick f3,5/135mm vs. Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm vs. Summicron f2/90mm at f5,6

    So, now we look at the Weltblick f3,5/135mm at different apertures:

    The scene is the same handmade glass picture, distance 4,00m, the sun is about 3,5cm, the big letters about 3mm high.

    I used Provia film modus at ISO800, clouded sky whitebalance, X-E1 on a tripod. All pictures are sooc jpeg's. I cropped them to the same size for better comparing.

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm full open / Weltblick f3,5/135mm at f5,6 / Weltblick f3,5/135mm at f8,0
    Weltblick 135 f3,5.JPG Weltblick 135 f5,6.JPG Weltblick 135 f8.JPG

    Images improved by closing the aperture.

    The Weltblick f3,5 / 135mm is a sharp lens. I don't want to say sharper as the Summicron, as the Summicron photos were much more cropped. The Weltblick for itself is a very small lens, but needs a much larger adapter as the Summicron. Considering the fact, that the Weltblick is available for 49,-€ at the bay and the Summicron costs 20 times more, this old manual focussing lens is a good bargain. The Tele-Ennalyt is not in the same class as the Weltblick or the Summicron. Furthermore the Weltblick is much better to focus. I wouldn't recommend to buy it.

    Chritics and Comments appreciated!


    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  4. Amin Sabet

    Amin Sabet Administrator

    792
    Jan 31, 2013
    Boston, MA (USA)
    Interesting lenses and findings!
     
  5. CaptZoom

    CaptZoom FujiXspot Regular

    166
    Mar 22, 2013
    Thank you for taking the time to purchase the equipment, doing the tests, and presenting the results. The Weltblick seems like outright theft at the quoted price:)
     
  6. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Hi, CaptZoom :tiphat:,
    I saw the Tele-Ennalyt on eBay and it pleased me because its a small good old style looking full machined metall lens. There is not so much information on sharpness in the net. Than you must feel the lens in your hand concerning focussing and so on...
    So, at first, i wanted to know for myself, how sharp the lens is, how it's performing in comparison with other lenses.
    Second, it's fun writing a kind of review :Dexter: and see, that other people like it. There is never enough information on this old lenses in the net. The more we all write in the forum, the more we can have fun with our bargains.

    :th_salute:fujidanny
     
  7. pniev

    pniev Guest

    Thanks for the review! Very informative. And I've learned about a few lenses I had never heard of before (yes, I know Leica ;) )
     
  8. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Some birds on the riverside...

    Hi :tiphat:,

    today i came along a river with a lot of birds and made some photos:
    It was a dull, grey and misty weather, so the photos can't be brilliant by that.

    Here ist the whole scene (X-E1, XF 18-55 at 18mm)

    DSCF2002.

    I took out my Weltblick f3,5 / 135mm, began to shoot:

    ... leader to wingman: we break through the little dugs...

    DSCF2007. f3,5


    ...ooooh, i have to clean my feathers...

    DSCF2017. f3,5


    The traffic sign about 150-200m away on the other riverside:

    DSCF2010.

    ... upps - i can read it :dance3:!


    So, what about the red container over there behind the lockage :confused:?

    DSCF2014. f5,6

    No, i can't read it :(.

    But :idea:: i bought a Weltblick 2x Extender, and we will see in the next post, how it performed.

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
    • Like Like x 1
  9. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Weltblick f3,5/135mm with 2x Extender

    Here again :tiphat:,

    we saw, that there are limitations to the Weltblick f3,5/135mm to make a photo of a ca. 250m away red container with a ca. 40x60 cm label. Handheld in a misty weather i can't read the about 10cm high letters...:(

    But, there are extenders, and the Weltblick 2x Extender, that i got for 24€ in the bay, performs quite good:

    The label on the 250m away container:

    DSCF2020. f5,6, 1/340s

    That's okay handhelt at 1/340s: 135mm x APS-C 1,5 x 2x Extender makes 405cm equivalent at full format (35mm film)

    Just cropping and 2 clicks in iPhoto and you can improve:

    DSCF2020 x2 f5,6 - cropped.JPG
    Level 26%-84%, sharpness 48%

    I think, a raw-shooter could be create even better results by smart post processing:encouragement:

    Some more birds:

    DSCF2022. DSCF2030. DSCF2031.

    I think, the sharpness is not comparable to the lens without the extender. But, i want to say, that this little piece of metal and glass isn't to bad to give it away - i will have some tripod shoots in bright weather to find a final decision.

    Critics and comments are appreciated :Dexter:
    Thank you! :hail:

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  10. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Ah, i found a good source for the lens:Weltblick is a trademark of german catalog company Neckermann Versand GmbH, Frankfurt and was built by Tomioka.
    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
    • Like Like x 1
  11. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Good and funny experiences with Weltblick f3,5/135mm

    Hello :tiphat:

    today, i made some good and some funny experience with my Weltblick f3,5/135mm:

    The good experience:

    DSCF2008.
    f5,6, Velvia, ISO 800, DR auto, sharp +1, SOOC JPEG

    DSCF2009.
    f5,6, Velvia, ISO 800, DR auto, sharp +1, SOOC JPEG

    DSCF2013.
    f3,5, B&W red filter, ISO 400, DR auto, Htone +1, Stone +1, SOOC JPEG

    The lens renders nice colors and really good plasticity!

    The funny experience:

    WB 135 dugs fringing.
    f5,6, Velvia, ISO 800, DR auto, sharp +1, SOOC JPEG

    On this photo i saw in iPhoto green colour fringing around the left dug and purple colour fringing at the right dug.
    But on those photos, i can't see it :cool: - can anybody explain this to me :confused::confused:?


    Okay, futher investigations are necessary :dejection:, a lot of fun with that lens-test :satellite:!

    Again, C&C appreciated!

    :th_salute: fujidanny
     
  12. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Like a phoenix from the ashes: Tele-Ennalyt goes macro!

    Hello :tiphat:

    the last days were a little bit disappointing :( , because i hoped the two old Weltblick and Enna lenses could satisfy me by sharpness and colour rendering.
    The Tele-Ennalyt f2,8 / 135mm showed great problems in sharpness, so that i didn't go on with further testing.
    The Weltblick f3,5 / 135mm is quite sharp, showed in further testing green and purple colour fringing.
    So, what to do :confused:?

    It's Easter Monday morning and the weather is fine, first flowers to see on the lawn, the bushes are in bud...
    Suddenly the idea :doh: :idea: : Didn't i buy those lovely old close-up rings by Schacht/Ulm a weak ago? They should fit very well to the Tele-Ennalyt. Let's have a look, how that functions!

    Yeah! That looks good! :)

    IMG_2208.
    X-E1, M42-X mount-adapter, 28mm Schacht close-up ring, Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135m (photo by iPhone 4s, pp in iPhoto)

    I used those setting:
    Velvia, ISO 400, F8, Exp.-2/3EV DRauto, WBauto, STone -1

    I stood about one meter away! What a plasticity!
    DSCF2024.

    Oh, what a boket! Okay, eversthing far away, but creamy as butter!
    DSCF2038.

    I would't say, thats unsharp! Again - nice boket...
    DSCF2040.

    Look at the colors!
    DSCF2061.

    I was really surprised - i wanted to sell that lens as fast as possible, but now i don't wanna miss it for such pictures :dance3::dance4::dance3:
    See more in the following post!

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  13. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    Hello :tiphat:

    Now, we wanna have a look on the more Leica-M-style looking Weltblick f3,5/135mm:

    IMG_2210.
    X-E1, M42-X mount-adapter, 28mm Schacht close-up ring, Weltblick f3,5/135mm (photo by iPhone 4s, pp in iPhoto)

    Sorry, that's in b&w - not that bad...
    DSCF2072.
    B&W red filter, ISO 400, F8, Exp.-2/3EV DRauto, WBauto, HTone +1 STone +1

    Than I used those setting:
    Velvia, ISO 400, F8, Exp.-2/3EV DRauto, WBauto, STone -1

    Oh, what a boket! Again, everything far away, but creamy as butter! And the main scene tack sharp!
    DSCF2087.

    This is very sharp, too! And really beautiful colors!
    DSCF2091.

    Again: sharp - nice boket...
    DSCF2079.

    Look at the colors!
    DSCF2086.

    I was really surprised - i was unhappy with the colour fringing, but in those views it is absolutely no problem :dance3::dance4::dance3:

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  14. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    And now: pie plants

    Hello :tiphat:

    Now i want to show you photos of both lenses side by side:

    Again i used those setting: Velvia, ISO 400, F8, Exp.-2/3EV DRauto, WBauto, STone -1

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm
    DSCF2102.
    DSCF2048.
    Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm
    DSCF2104.
    DSCF2050.
    Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm

    :th_salute: Fujidanny
     
  15. fujidanny

    fujidanny FujiXspot Regular

    54
    Feb 11, 2013
    B&W - Contrast and Boket

    Hello :tiphat:

    Now i want to show you b&w photos of both lenses side by side:

    I used those settings: B&W red filter, ISO 400, F8, Exp.-2/3EV DRauto, WBauto, HTone +1, STone +1

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm
    DSCF2077.
    DSCF2067.
    Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm

    Weltblick f3,5/135mm
    DSCF2073.
    DSCF2070.
    Tele-Ennalyt f2,8/135mm

    Help, please help :hail: I can't see the difference, give me some comments :Dexter:, please!
    They look all so good, whether color nor b&w: i don't know what to say :dance3::dance4::dance3:

    Verdict: Don't think too bad about a lens, before you didn't try it out in different ways - you never know, what the best performance is, unless you test it in different situations. Both lenses perform very well out in the field, any sharpness tests don't give you the right info on a lens, there are much more things to proof. Both lenses render a beautiful boket, sometimes the softness of the Tele-Ennalyt is the bringer.
    keep in mind, the Weltblick costs about 50-75€ (75-100$), the Tele-Ennalyt 20-35€ (30-45$). They are both good bargains.


    Some discuss: is the X-E1 the new Leica M? I think it's a good alternative with all those beautiful old manual focus lenses.
    I love my 18-55 very much, especially, when i'm out with the family - not to much time for focussing and so on.
    But: When I am out to celebrate good old school photography, to come down and relax, there is nothing giving more fun to me as those old manual focussing lenses, thinking about the best view, zooming by feet...

    Cheers!

    :th_salute: Fujidanny